PC Magazine, March 12, 1996 v15 n5 p34(1)
Do you believe everything you download? Disinformation and urban
legends on the Net. (Industry Trend or Event)(Brief Article) Jonathan Karl
Matzkin.
Full Text: COPYRIGHT 1996 Ziff-Davis Publishing Company Online communications
may have
a dark side that has nothing at all to do with hackers, credit card thieves,
or kiddy porn. Bulletin
boards, online services, and the Internet provide unprecedented mobility
of information, but new
communications technologies in no way change age-old human propensities
to lie, gossip, or simply
repeat bad information.
Recent examples of online disinformation suggest that the Internet is not
only a source of new
rumors but also a fertile new ground for older urban legends that refuse
to die. The furor over
CompuServe's decision to drop hundreds of newsgroups from its Usenet server
is one example.
Before CompuServe made a statement about the move, a rash of wildly speculative
postings to
several Usenet groups advanced the idea that CompuServe's action came in
response to the passage
of restrictive telecommunications legislation by the U.S. Congress. CompuServe
flatly denied the
claims and attributed the move to demands made by German government officials.
While CompuServe's motives may be open to some debate, the status of the
telecomm bill at the
time of this writing is not. It has neither cleared Congress nor been signed
by the President. Yet the
idea that it has become law was accepted in some subsequent postings as
the truth and became the
premise for discussions containing heated calls to action.
Electronic mail, too, can be a potent disinformation tool. Rumors of an
attempted hostile takeover of
Apple Computer by Sony were touched off by a bogus e-mail message recently
circulated on the
Internet. Apple became aware of the message on January 9, a spokesperson
said, and the company
received approximately 25 inquiries as to its legitimacy in the succeeding
few days. Sony posted a
statement on the Business Wire on January 12 declaring the transmission
a hoax.
Industry observer Esther Dyson, president of EDventure Holdings, notes,
"Just as the Net is a
better forum for information, so it is a better forum for disinformation."
She adds that the
conveniences of online communication help information travel faster with
less effort.
While the Internet may be "a fertile ground" for disinformation, Mike Godwin,
an attorney with the
Electronic Frontier Foundation, says, "It is wrong to say there is something
inherently sinister about
the Internet or online speech." Godwin cautions against jumping to conclusions
about whether the
Internet is a better medium for disinformation than traditional means of
communication.
Source: PC Data. Data for November. For additional lists, see http://www.ziff.com/~pcmag/topten.
Article A17984929